Tibetans born & raised in plains grow taller
November 16, 2007
The Telegraph, India[Monday, November 12, 2007 10:24]
By G.S. MUDUR
New Delhi, November 11 - Tibetans who were born and raised in India
are taller and display other physiological changes that are not
observed among original Tibetan highlanders, Calcutta-based
scientists have found.
The changes are among the first signals that Tibetans - the world's
longest-surviving high altitude residents - are adapting to the low
altitude environment in India, anthropologists at the Indian
Statistical Institute (ISI), Calcutta, said.
Their studies show that Tibetan men and women between the ages of 18
and 40 who were raised at low altitudes in India are on an average
about 4 to 5cm taller than their counterparts in high altitude regions.
"Among all human populations, Tibetans have adapted best to the high
altitude environment," said Ranjan Gupta, head of the ISI's
biological anthropology unit. "It's possible we're now looking at a
reversal of this adaptation," Gupta told The Telegraph.
Gupta and researcher Vikal Tripathy studied body features of Tibetans
in three settlements at different altitudes in India - Choglamsar in
Leh at 3500m above sea level where the environment is similar to the
high altitude regions of Tibet, a settlement in Chandragiri (Orissa)
and another at Bylakuppe (Karnataka), both within 1000m above sea level.
The lower height of Tibetans at Choglamsar might be explained through
low oxygen in the air and relatively poor nutrition in high altitude
regions, the researchers said, presenting their findings in the
American Journal of Human Biology. Populations at low altitudes have
access to a greater diversity of vegetables and fruits in winter than
people living at high altitudes.
"Everyone has genetic potential... when the different stresses
associated with high altitude are removed, the genetic potential gets
activated," said Gupta.
"This is very significant work. It's the first time anyone has
systematically looked at Tibetans at different altitudes," said
Charles Weitz, chairman of anthropology at Temple University,
Philadelphia, in the US. Weitz is an authority on adaptation to high
altitude environments, having studied populations in South America
and China.
Archaeological evidence suggests that humans had settled in Tibet
around 20,000 years ago, long before any other population had settled
in high altitude zones around the world.
Scientists believe both the genetic make-up and the environment
contribute to human growth and development. "This study is part of a
broader effort to determine how much of human adaptation is driven by
the genes and how much by the environment," Weitz said.
Gupta and Weitz are now writing a proposal for a joint study to
pursue this line of research in finer detail. "India offers a unique
natural environment for such a study," Gupta said. Some 80,000
Tibetans fled their native land in 1959 and have settled in India
where the environment is very different from that found on the
Tibetan plateau.
The ISI study also found that Tibetans living at low altitudes had
slightly higher values of weight, skin-fold thickness at the triceps,
and upper arm circumference. The researchers believe greater physical
activity may be causing Tibetans at low altitudes to gain more weight
than Tibetans living at high altitudes.
"Some changes may also relate to body surface area. In extreme cold,
a low surface area helps the body retain heat, but this is not
necessary at low altitudes," Gupta said. "Better nutrition and the
absence of high altitude stress - both might be driving the changes
we're seeing," he said.