Join our Mailing List

"Canada can, within a positive friendly atmosphere, ask the Chinese government to resolve the Tibetan situation."

Is the Dalai Lama About to Give Up On China?

October 28, 2008

By Simon Elegant / Beijing
October 27, 2008

Has the Dalai Lama really given up on hope that China might some day
come around and agree to his proposal for some sort of (very) limited
autonomy for his homeland, Tibet? That's what the 73-year-old exiled
Tibetan spiritual leader appeared to indicate during an Oct. 25
speech in his exile home of Dharamsala in northern India. "I have
been sincerely pursuing the middle way approach in dealing with China
for a long time now but there hasn't been any positive response from
the Chinese side," he was quoted as saying. "As far as I'm concerned
I have given up." That was, as an Associated Press report on the
speech noted —almost with shock — "an unusually blunt" statement from
a man whose well-known global public image revolves around preaching
the compromise and non-violence that are central tenets of Buddhism.

But it appears that after decades of fruitless negotiations with
Beijing as part of an attempt to gain some concessions for his
homeland, the 15th Dalai Lama may have finally reached the end of his
tether. "Mr. Patience has run out of patience," says Robbie Barnett,
a professor of Tibetan studies at Columbia University in New York
City. "It's really very serious indeed and a major disappointment,
though not so much of a surprise. The Chinese must have know this was
coming — some of the responsible officials in fact must be very
pleased that they have managed to provoke this reaction. Now they can
say that it was the other side that broke off negotiations, and claim
the moral high ground."

The eighth round of talks between Beijing officials and the Dalai
Lama's representatives was scheduled for late October. It's not clear
how the statements by the Dalai Lama will affect them. On the day
after the speech, the Tibetan leader's spokesman Tenzin Taklha told
reporters that the talks were set to go forward as scheduled,
stressing the need to "keep the door to dialog open." Taklha also
confirmed that the Dalai Lama had called a consultative meeting of
exiled Tibetans for mid-November at which the group's approach to
achieving their goal of a freer Tibet would be completely examined
from the ground up. He said "everything will be on the table" for
reconsideration except the fundamental principle of non-violence.

In March, anti-Chinese riots in the Tibetan capital Lhasa did turn
violent, leading to scores of fatalities on both sides. Chinese
authorities swiftly sealed off Tibet and rounded up hundreds of
suspects, some of whom reportedly remain in jail nearly eight months
later. With access to the region still almost completely blocked,
there have been only intermittent reports of further protests and
alleged abuses and human rights violations by Chinese security forces
attempting to quash the simmering dissent. Resentment against Beijing
has exploded sporadically among the roughly six million Tibetans
living in the mountainous region ever since troops of the People's
Liberation Army invaded in 1951.

The Dalai Lama fled his homeland for exile in India in 1951, and has
since become a familiar, maroon-robed presence on the world stage in
a tireless, peripatetic campaign to win his homeland some degree of
autonomy and preserve Tibet's traditional culture. This year he has
found himself in an increasingly impossible situation since the riots
in March, analysts and academics say. Younger and more radical forces
among the some 100,000-strong exile community in India have
increasingly called for a tougher stance against Beijing,
particularly as reports of alleged further abuse, including arrests
and shootings of demonstrating monks, have grown.

Sources familiar with the Tibetan stance say they have dropped almost
all preconditions in talks with the Chinese and were seeking only a
meeting between the spiritual leader and Chinese president Hu Jintao.
but rather than soften their position, Chinese officials seemed to
grow more aggressive since the middle of this year, most recently
stating in July that the talks were not about the future of Tibet but
about arrangements for the Dalai Lama's own future, including when he
might be allowed to return to China. "That's exactly what caused the
collapse of talks all the way back in 1985," says Barnett. "They must
have known what would happen if they humiliated him that way again."
Once they had returned to that phraseology, Barnett says the Dalai
Lama had almost no choice but to repudiate them. Considering
everything, he says, "the only real surprise is that it took so long."
CTC National Office 1425 René-Lévesque Blvd West, 3rd Floor, Montréal, Québec, Canada, H3G 1T7
T: (514) 487-0665
Developed by plank