Join our Mailing List

"For a happier, more stable and civilized future, each of us must develop a sincere, warm-hearted feeling of brotherhood and sisterhood."

TIANANMEN 20 YEARS ON: Study slams China on democracy

June 8, 2009

DISTORTION: A Freedom House study says state-controlled news organizations
plan to spend billions of dollars in an attempt to improve China’s image

By William Lowther
Taipei Times
Friday, Jun 05, 2009, Page 3

An extensive new study finds that China is actively undermining democracy at
home and abroad and conducting an “organized, sophisticated and
well-resourced” campaign to subvert organizations that promote human rights.

Along with Russia, Iran, Venezuela and Pakistan, the study says that China
serves as a “model of authoritarianism for the 21st century.”

Entitled Undermining Democracy the study has been produced by Freedom House
— a US-based international non-governmental organization that researches
democracy, political freedom and human rights — and was released on the 20th
anniversary of the 1989 Tiananmen Square crackdown.

There are five key findings.

By doling out billions of dollars in no-strings-attached foreign aid, China
and the other four regimes are hobbling international efforts to improve
governance and reduce corruption; they are disrupting the human rights and
democracy work of international bodies such as the UN; they are tarnishing
the public understanding of democracy by distorting its meaning through
well-financed international media ventures; they are stopping legitimate
online political debate; and they are distorting history and creating a new
generation that is hostile toward democracy and suspicious of the outside

Libby Liu (??), president of Radio Free Asia and one of the analysts
involved in the study, said: “China has modernized its strategy of

“The sophistication of media management by the Chinese authorities,
including market-based censorship combined with more traditional methods of
intimidation, suggests a system that is both repressive and resilient,” she


According to the study, China’s state-controlled news organizations plan to
spend billions of dollars on expanding overseas media operations in a bid to
improve the country’s image abroad by opening more overseas bureaus,
publishing more content in English and other languages and hiring
English-speaking Chinese and foreign media specialists.

It says: “China is ruled by the CCP hierarchy, which has both enriched
itself and maintained the necessary degree of public support by opening up
new fields of economic and commercial activity.”

“Paradoxically, the party has won praise as the guarantor of national
prosperity simply by removing its own long-standing restrictions, allowing
the Chinese people to climb out of the crushing poverty and social
devastation that had resulted from decades of CCP rule. China’s rise has
been so dramatic precisely because its starting point was so low,” it says.

The study argues that Beijing has burnished its image by the “studious
repression of critical voices.”

It adds that the CCP has “seriously distorted” Chinese history by practicing
censorship, twisting textbooks, producing inaccurate television
documentaries and promoting false museum exhibits.

“Ongoing and growing problems — pollution, human rights abuses, galloping
corruption and social unrest stemming from basic injustice — are largely
papered over through the same mechanisms of repression and media control,”
the study says.

But it concludes that on the domestic front the CCP is more frightened of
its own citizenry than most outside observers realize.

“The top priority of the CCP remains today what it always has been:
maintaining absolute political power,” the study says.

It continues: “No other goal — be it economic, military, diplomatic or
nationalistic — trumps this aim. Indeed, the recent economic downturn is of
great concern to the CCP precisely because it threatens the party’s hold on

Among the population at large, there is a “fear-induced self-censorship.”

The study explains: “In Mao’s day, expression had to stay within certain
bounds, while everything outside was forbidden.”

“Today, one can explore anything beyond certain forbidden topics: the 1989
Tiananmen Massacre, the Falun Gong movement, the China Democratic Party,
Taiwan independence, Tibetan or Uighur autonomy, the Great Leap famine,
corruption among top leaders and certain other incorrect views on national
or international affairs,” it adds.

Young Chinese today, says the study, may be well educated in mathematics,
engineering, or languages and yet live with badly warped understandings of
their nation’s past.

“Even worse, they could remain entirely unaware of how they have been
cheated,” the study says.

Textbooks stress that certain people in Taiwan want to “split the
motherland” and the true history of the Mao era — including the histories of
Tibet, Taiwan, World War II and the CCP itself — is routinely omitted.

The study says: “The CCP sometimes fabricates or exaggerates national-level
fears precisely for the purpose of distracting attention. Most Chinese
people, left to themselves, care much more about their own daily lives than
about distant places like Taiwan or Tibet. They wake up in the morning
worried more about a corrupt local official than about the Dalai Lama.”


“But when CCP propaganda tells them repeatedly that the wolf-hearted Dalai
Lama is splitting the motherland, they tend to embrace the view that it is
bad to split the motherland and that the CCP is the standard-bearer in
opposing the splitting,” it says.

“The stimulation of a fear that did not previously exist has less to do with
actual danger than with the CCP’s need to strengthen its popular image and
divert attention from popular complaints. In recent years the CCP has used
incidents involving Japan, Tibet, Taiwan and the United States for this
purpose. In the case of Tibet there is evidence that the triggering
incidents themselves have been manufactured for the cause,” it says.
CTC National Office 1425 René-Lévesque Blvd West, 3rd Floor, Montréal, Québec, Canada, H3G 1T7
T: (514) 487-0665
Developed by plank