Join our Mailing List

"On my part, I remain committed to the process of dialogue. It is my firm belief that dialogue and a willingness to look with honesty and clarity at the reality of Tibet can lead us to a viable solution."

New Challenges for the Tibet Movement in Europe

July 4, 2009

tibet-envoy.eu 02 July 2009

by Kelsang Gyaltsen, Envoy of His Holiness the Dalai Lama

Sometime after the bloody crackdown of the students' led demonstrations for
democracy at Tiananmen Square in 1989 when China re-emerged on the world
stage from political isolation, some political analysts contended that the
issue of Tibet would be marginalised as a result of the growing economic and
political clout of China. I never shared this view. Mainly because of my
fundamental belief that the importance and urgency of the issue of Tibet
will be first and foremost determined by the state of affairs inside Tibet
and by the determination and aspirations of the Tibetan people.

2008: A turning-point in the Tibetan freedom struggle

In the past 60 years of its rule in Tibet, Beijing has left no doubt about
its resolve to root out the issue of Tibet once and for all. With this
resolve China has experimented with varying degrees of repression in Tibet
in the past decades. But all these policies have been misguided due to a
fundamental lack of understanding, appreciation and respect for Tibet's
distinct culture, history and identity. Instead of pursuing a policy that
aims to win the hearts and minds of the Tibetans, Beijing has been
consistently relying on the use of force and coercion as the principal means
to rule and administer Tibet.

As a consequence of these misguided policies, today the spirit of resistance
of the Tibetan people is stronger than ever. The Tibetan resistance and
freedom movement, which started in the 1950s, has been carried on up to the
present by Tibetans belonging to the generations of the 20th century.
However, last year the demonstrations of Tibetans throughout the Tibetan
plateau signalled an important turning-point: that today the Tibetan
resistance and freedom movement has been taken over by Tibetans belonging to
the generations of the 21st century - who have been born and grown up under
Chinese rule.

The uprising of Tibetan generations of the 21st century last year has
brought the issue of Tibet once more to the focal point of world attention
and has put it firmly on the political agenda of this century. Obviously
this problem is going to stay unless it is addressed in a realistic and
proper way and resolved through honest and earnest dialogue and
negotiations. It is a dangerous political miscalculation and
wishful-thinking to hope that this issue will gradually go-away own its own.
Moreover, the events of last year in Tibet also demonstrated clearly how
events in Tibet can seriously disrupt China's relations with the rest of the
world and her standing in the world.

Impacts of China's growing role in the world

I have always been of the view that the more a country gains on importance
on the world stage the more attention is being paid to all aspects of the
state of affairs of that country by members of the international community.
Since the issue of Tibet has a bearing on the stability and unity of the
People's Republic of China, I have been of the opinion that the cause of
Tibet will continue to receive rather more attention and to gain more
significance in accordance with the increasing stature of China in the
world.

Nonetheless, it is also an undeniable reality that the political environment
in which the Tibet movement has been operating so far has changed
significantly in recent times. China's position in the world has become
considerably stronger. For most governments in Europe, China has become an
important international partner. Their relationship with China is broad,
multi-faceted, comprehensive and vital in a number of areas.

Against this background the Tibet movement is facing a changed political
environment.

Europe's policy of engagement and quiet diplomacy with China

In my recent discussions with a number of governments in Europe, I have
gained the impression that the issue of Tibet is taken very seriously today.
Tibet is being raised in bilateral and multilateral relations with China by
European governments at various levels, including at summits. Since last
year's crisis in Tibet it is noticeable that there is greater awareness of
the seriousness and urgency of the issue of Tibet among many European
governments. As a result, it is my impression that there is greater resolve
among these European governments to address the issue of Tibet with their
Chinese counterparts with a greater sense of awareness, urgency and
perseverance.

On the other hand, it is also a fact that is becoming clearer today that
European governments are more hesitant and reluctant to criticise China
publicly about human rights and Tibet. In addition to the growing importance
of China as a global actor, there has always been a school of thought that
contends that "quiet diplomacy" is the more effective way to enhance human
rights, greater openness and more democracy in China. This view has been
rebutted as a fatal fallacy by the political development of the past years
and the current state of affairs in China. Sadly, many governments still
continue to advance this position. It is difficult to say whether they do so
just out of political expediency or on account of lack of viable policy
alternatives.

Shortcomings and negative consequences of the policy of "quiet diplomacy"

The debate among politicians, diplomats and political analysts about how
human rights, rule of law and democracy in China can be best encouraged and
promoted is a valid and important one. However, these debates focus
exclusively on the Chinese leadership and government and ignore completely
the forces of human rights and democracy in China. There is a total lack of
appreciation and understanding of the role and importance that Chinese
movements for democracy and human rights are playing and will continue to
play in bringing about these changes in China. Ultimately, respect for basic
civil and political rights in the PRC can only be restored and ensured if
the forces of democracy and human rights in China prevail. Unfortunately,
this aspect of the issue - the support and encouragement of forces for human
rights and democracy in China - has so far been totally side-stepped in
these debates.

The absence of public expression of concern and solidarity is a very serious
matter for oppressed and persecuted people. Hope and vision are their sole
source of strength and inspiration in a situation marked by intimidation,
coercion and terror. The knowledge that there are people in the world who
recognize the suffering and injustice they are undergoing, who have not
abandoned them and who work and call for their freedom is a tremendous
source of encouragement, inspiration and strength. Expressions of public
concern and solidarity are the oxygen for the flame of hope and vision of
oppressed people everywhere. Therefore, it is precisely for this reason why
the oppressors condemn so strongly such acts as "interference in internal
affairs" and are so insistent on dialogue "behind closed doors". It is an
important feature of their psychological warfare against human rights and
democracy activists. Obviously, no amount of brutal oppression has such
devastating effect on the hope, morale and will of the oppressed as the
feeling of being forgotten, abandoned and their agony and suffering ignored
by the world and fellow human beings.

Power politic versus People's power

The importance of public gestures and expressions of sympathy, support and
solidarity has been clearly demonstrated by different movements in the past.
The cases in point are the movements against Apartheid, the Vietnam War etc.
In Europe, the important role of such gestures and expressions in sustaining
the hope, courage and vision of those oppressed is well-documented by
testimonies of human rights and democracy activists in former Communist
countries in Europe.

In the light of political constraints that many governments in Europe seem
to feel with regard to public expression of criticism of China's repressive
policies in Tibet, obviously, the Tibet movement in Europe is facing a
changed political environment. The restraint exercised by governments in
criticising China publicly may require that the Tibet movement review and
reconsider its priorities and activities. The logical conclusion out of the
new political reality would seem to counter-balance the absence of formal or
official public expression of concern and support through public acts of
support and solidarity directly by ordinary citizens and the media.

The Berlin Solidarity Rally with the People of Tibet

In May last year the German Tibet Support Group (Tibet Initiative
Deutschland) and the local Tibetan community organised a solidarity rally
for Tibet on the occasion of His Holiness the Dalai Lama's visit to Berlin.
Twenty-five thousand Germans assembled at Berlin's Brandenburg Gate to show
their support for and solidarity with the Tibetan people and His Holiness
the Dalai Lama. It was a massive and most impressive show of public support
for and solidarity with the non-violent freedom struggle of the Tibetan
people. No message to the Chinese government as well as to the German
government could have been clearer and stronger than this peaceful gathering
of thousands of free citizens for a common purpose and with a common message
on Tibet.

The rally conveyed some important messages. Firstly, it demonstrated to the
German government the strong support for the cause of Tibet and for His
Holiness the Dalai Lama among the German population. The rally was, thus,
also a compelling call on the German government to act on Tibet. Secondly,
the wide press and media coverage of the rally coupled with the huge
presence of 25.000 people demonstrated clearly that the issue of Tibet is an
issue of national concern to the people of the Federal Republic of Germany.
As such it is an issue that cannot be ignored in the bilateral relationship
between Germany and China.

Thirdly, the rally made clear to the Chinese government that it may be able
to exert pressure on governments on the issue of Tibet but that it cannot
bully the German public and media into silence. On the contrary, the more
restraint governments may feel compelled to exercise under Chinese pressure,
the more ordinary citizens with a sense of justice and human solidarity with
the weak and persecuted will feel the need to act on their own. This was
exactly what happened in the case of the "Berlin Solidarity Rally with
Tibet". The German Chancellor, Angela Merkel, was on a visit abroad when His
Holiness visited Berlin. The Foreign Minister, Mr. Steinmeier, and the
President of Germany, M. Horst Köhler, both declined to meet with His
Holiness. This situation motivated the German Tibet Support Group and the
local Tibetan Community to organise this rally and thousands of Germans to
follow the call on their own free will and at their own expense. The rally
was organised within 10 days demonstrating impressively the popular appeal
and the strong base of support of the cause of Tibet in Germany.

The importance of sending the right signals to China

Irrespective of the current very grim situation inside Tibet and the
deadlock in the dialogue process between the envoys of His Holiness the
Dalai Lama and the Chinese leadership, there are sufficient reasons for hope
and optimism that the future of Tibet and China will move beyond mistrust
and enmity to a relationship based on mutual respect, trust and recognition
of common interest. This process and development can be encouraged, enhanced
and accelerated significantly by sending the right kind of message and
signal to the Chinese government by members of the international community,
the world public and media. In this context each individual can contribute
and make a difference by speaking out and acting on Tibet. There is no doubt
that the continued expression of concern about and support for Tibet
worldwide will, in the long run, have a positive impact and help create the
necessary political environment for a peaceful resolution of the issue of
Tibet.

CTC National Office 1425 René-Lévesque Blvd West, 3rd Floor, Montréal, Québec, Canada, H3G 1T7
T: (514) 487-0665   ctcoffice@tibet.ca
Developed by plank