Join our Mailing List

"As long as human rights are violated, there can be no foundation for peace. How can peace grow where speaking the truth is itself a crime?"

China's Civil Rights Lawyers: The New Enemies of the State

July 22, 2009

Rebecca Novick, Huffington Post

Posted: July 20, 2009 12:44 PM

Apart from crackdowns in its ethnic minority regions of Xinjiang and
Tibet, in recent months Beijing has been busy targeting home-grown
adversaries--Chinese civil rights lawyers--in a series of moves that has
been described by the group Human Rights in China as "an all-out attack."

On the morning of Friday, July 17, around 20 Beijing Civil Affairs
Bureau officials raided the offices of the nongovernmental legal
research center, Open Constitution Initiative (OCI). The officials took
away the centers files, computers and other equipment in an operation
that lasted four and a half hours, and an order delivered to the staff
that the center was to be shut down "effective upon announcement."

Three days earlier, on July 14, the OCI had received notification of
fines from state and local Beijing tax bureaus totaling $208,000 (1.42
million yuan) for alleged tax violations.

Founded in 2002, OCI, part of the Gongmeng Consulting group, is run by
human rights lawyers who take on cases that might be deemed sensitive
for Beijing, most notably preparing a public lawsuit on behalf of
victims of the tainted milk scandal who could not afford representation.
This May, the center came out with a report critical of Beijing's
policies in Tibet, suggesting that Tibetans are not benefiting from
China's development in the region and that Tibetans who protested last
year were venting "reasonable demands." [See Huffington Post article]

On the Chinese Law Prof's blog George Washington University Law School
professor Donald C. Clarke notes, "One can reasonably suspect that more
is going on here that just tax problems."

The official reason for why OCI was shut down was that it had not
registered as a nonprofit or "civil society" organization with the
government and was running as a business. The fine included penalties
made against a number of endowments given to OCI by Yale Law School. On
July 18th, Paul Gerwitz, Yale Law School professor and the director of
Yale's China Law Center, issued a statement in support of OCI and Xu
Zhiyong, saying, "We hope that its valuable work can continue. We also
hope that the relevant Chinese authorities will reconsider these
penalties and decisions once they have obtained additional information
from OCI at the requested hearings."

Xu Zhiyong the passionate civil rights activist and legal scholar who
founded OCI admits there may have been some accounting errors, but
claims that there is "no legal proof to show our group has not been
registered properly." He believes that the center's closure was
politically motivated. In a statement on his blog, Zhiyong writes, "It's
not just a punishment against us, it is punishing the children poisoned
by milk powder, the kids of migrant workers, the property owners bullied
by developers, and those petitioners who tirelessly demand justice."
[See Xu Zhiyong's full statement]

"This is precisely the kind of organization whose work the government
should value, as it helps ease grievances and minimize unrest," said
Sophie Richardson, Asia advocacy director at Human Rights Watch.

?Petitioners in China: By removing legal avenues for their frustrations
is Beijing ?courting social unrest? [Photo: China Digital Times]

More reports continue to surface in China of legal licenses being
revoked or refused renewal, suspensions of lawyers, and the forced
closure of law firms. Some lawyers have not received their annual
licensing inspection and registration approval from the Lawyers
Association, without which they cannot legally continue to practice.
According to Human Rights in China, three Beijing law firms who did not
pass their annual inspection were told that the reason they failed was
because "they represented mass cases without going through the proper
procedures." Most of the 17 lawyers have taken on cases involving Falun
Gong, HIV/AIDS, peasants in land disputes, forced evictions, the
melamine milk powder scandal, and religious freedom.

Human Rights Watch is reporting that the official Beijing Bureau of
Legal Affairs issued a notice to the city's lawyers urging "caution" in
their involvement in the defense of suspects linked to the July 5 riots
in Urumqi in Xinjiang. This will not be viewed as an idle threat. A
number of Beijing lawyers who offered to represent Tibetans following
the March 2008 protests had their licenses revoked as a result.

The Human Rights in China website lists a number of cases where more
aggressive tactics than bureaucratic obstacles and intimidation have
been used against lawyers who take on such cases, including arrests,
disappearances, and beatings. On February 28, Wei Liangwan, a lawyer
from Heilongjiang Province who has taken up a number of religious
freedom cases, was arrested by Harbin police. In April, Yang Zaixin, a
lawyer from Guangxi Province representing farmers who had lost their
land, was beaten severely. Liu Yao, who was representing peasants in
land disputes, was sentenced to a one-year prison term with a two-year
reprieve. On May 13th, around 20 policemen broke into the house of the
client of two Beijing lawyers, Zhang Kai and Li Chunfu, working in
Chongqing. The lawyers were handcuffed and beaten.??The Associated Press
reported that on July 9, the Beijing Justice Bureau announced through
its website that it had canceled the licenses of 53 lawyers for
allegedly failing to apply for re-registration. The disbarred lawyers
include the renowned civil rights lawyer, Jiang Tianyong, whose clients
have included high-profile Tibetan monks and victims of a slave labor ring.

But in removing the legal channels through which ordinary Chinese
citizens can voice their grievances, some observers worry that Beijing
might be unwittingly fueling less civilized methods of getting heard.

Says Human Rights Watch's Sophie Richardson, "The Chinese government has
a choice: it can let people take their cases through the courts, or it
can let them take to the street."

Rebecca Novick is a writer and founding producer of The Tibet Connection
radio program.
CTC National Office 1425 René-Lévesque Blvd West, 3rd Floor, Montréal, Québec, Canada, H3G 1T7
T: (514) 487-0665   ctcoffice@tibet.ca
Developed by plank