Join our Mailing List

"We Tibetans are looking for a legitimate and meaningful autonomy, an arrangement that would enable Tibetans to live within the framework of the People’s Republic of China."

China's Tibet claim 'not well-founded'

March 11, 2009

Legal brief from 1950 reveals Canada long held doubts about annexation
By Mike Blanchfield and Aileen McCabe, Canwest News Service
The Ottawa Citizen (Canada)
March 11, 2009

On Tuesday's 50th anniversary of the Tibetan uprising, the Dalai Lama called the Chinese control of his former homeland "hell on earth."

But almost a decade before that ill-fated 1959 rebellion against China's powerful military, one that ultimately drove the young 14th Dalai Lama into exile, Canada's then-External Affairs department essentially concluded the Chinese incursion was a violation Tibet's nationhood.

"The question is, should Canada consider Tibet to be an independent state, a vassal of China, or an integral portion of China. It is submitted that the Chinese claim to sovereignty over Tibet is not well-founded," says the Nov. 21, 1950, legal opinion by External Affairs, which has since been declassified.

The opinion, stamped "confidential" at the time, was circulated to Canada's embassy in Washington and its mission at the United Nations in New York.

The collection of diplomatic cables and memorandums, spanning the Second World War to the 1960s, has since been released by the National Archives. It offers a unique historical glimpse into Canada's connection to the Tibetan problem that simmers to this day.

"Canada has serious concerns about the human-rights situation in China, including in Tibet, and raises these concerns with the Chinese government at every appropriate opportunity," Foreign Affairs Minister Lawrence Cannon told Canwest News Service on Tuesday in an e-mail.

"Canada regularly calls on the Government of China to respect the right of Tibetans to protest peacefully, and to take steps to improve the human-rights situation in Tibet.

"Canada has consistently advocated substantive dialogue between the People's Republic of China and the Dalai Lama, or his designated representatives."

Tuesday's anniversary was marked by pro-Tibetan rallies and protests in Canadian cities, and dozens more across the globe, in addition to the Dalai Lama's own statement.

In Tibet, under the watchful eye of a massive security force, the anniversary passed without reports of the kinds of demonstrations that developed into riots last year and left scores of people dead and wounded.

Foreign journalists are banned from the Tibetan plateau area, but China's state-owned news agency, Xinhua, reported only one incident late Monday night in the Tibetan area of Qinghai Province where a police car and fire truck were destroyed by homemade explosives.

The news agency's summary of the day's events in Lhasa said: "The holy city of Lhasa was quiet and peaceful Tuesday, the day marking 50 years since Tibet's democratic reform."

China's military annexed Tibet in 1950, saying they were liberating the Tibetans from feudal serfdom.

Today, the Chinese Communist government has all but vilified the Dalai Lama, branding him a separatist agitator.

Speaking to thousands of his supporters from Dharamsala, the Indian town that houses Tibet's government in exile, Tibet's 73-year-old spiritual leader renewed his call Tuesday for China to recognize "legitimate and meaningful autonomy" for Tibet as he characterized the decades of suffering as "hell on earth" for the people there.

In 1950, Canada's External Affairs department reached the legal conclusion that Tibet had demonstrated its historical independence from China.

"Chinese suzerainty, perhaps existent, though ill-defined, before 1911, appears since then, on the basis of facts available to us, to have been a mere fiction," the document concluded.

"In fact, it appears that, during the past 40 years, Tibet has controlled its own internal and external affairs. Viewing the situation thus, I am of the opinion that Tibet is, from the point of view of international law, qualified for recognition as an independent state."

Xinhua, in reporting Tuesday on clashes between police with protesters in Nepal, summarized the historical context this way:

"Fifty years ago, the central government of China foiled the armed rebellion started on March 10 by the Dalai Lama and his supporters to block the reform of feudal serfdom in Tibet and split the region from China. ... The Dalai Lama and his followers, since their exile, have continued to pursue either disguised or undisguised activities to separate Tibet from China and restore feudal serfdom in the region."

In October 2007, Prime Minister Stephen Harper hosted the Dalai Lama on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, the first time a Canadian leader met him in an official venue. The Chinese Embassy in Ottawa denounced Harper's decision.
CTC National Office 1425 René-Lévesque Blvd West, 3rd Floor, Montréal, Québec, Canada, H3G 1T7
T: (514) 487-0665
Developed by plank